Telephone : (919) 401-4224

Hours : Click Here


Get 10% Off Your First Online Order.

Our Menu

Our Story

We have been in the pizza business since 1988 when we started in Manhattan New York. was Opened in 2003 and it was a success storey since then for one Reason, (WE MAKE THE ORIGNAL NEW YORK STYLE PIZZAS, that brings the taste of Manhattan to you.)
Visit our location in New Hope Commons Shopping Center, Durham& You will experience Manhattan without leaving North Carolina.

Our menu features many mouth-watering dishes including amazing specials like our award winning speicaltiy pizza and scratch made ny strombolis. We love doing our part to feed the local community.
Try us out today, you will not be disappointed! All new first time carry out orders through our website qualify for a 10% discount and $5 off for every $100 spent. Enjoy!

Special Online Offers

Get 10% Off Your First Online Order

Every Time You Spend $100 Online = $5 Off Your Next Online Order

Customer Reviews

Jeffrey White

This place is a buried treasure back in the shopping center. Pizza slices were hot, melty, huge, and delicious. The service of these guys was impeccable. They saw we were on a date and even let me pay after eating and brought a complimentary sundae to our table. It was a wonderful experience.


We tried their meat lover pizza (ham, bacon and pepperoni) but barely tasted and found any bacon...and the dough was not to our taste either, kinda soggy and not thin to say we were pretty disappointed with the pizza there.

Katelyn G

Friendly service, and pretty fast too. The only reason I didn't give 5 stars is because the prices tend to get kind of high, especially on the cake slices and ice cream but other than that, I have no complaints.

FaZe King

We travel to Durham EVERY weekend and the first thing my son says is "Can we go to 'I heart NY pizza'". Not only is the pizza delicious but the customer service is GREAT!! Highly recommended!

Bibi Rivera

I Love New York Pizza, was so delicious!! We are 4 soccer teams that traveled from Atlanta to play soccer in Raleigh. We called Fafe in the afternoon and he was able to cater for 60 people with pasta, knots, salad, & pizza . The food was not only DELICIOUS but there was so much food!

Mike Marchetto

I grew up in a pizzeria in the north east and I can say this place definitely feels authentic. They have a lot of options including pizza by the slice. The variety is a little all over the place honestly; Greek, pizza, Ice cream..